Beginning git project for FEM code. Still need to add examples, documentation, and testing.

CMakeLists.txt

+include_directories(${CMAKE_INSTALL_PREFIX}/include)
+
+include_directories( "${CMAKE_CURRENT_SOURCE_DIR}/include" )
+add_subdirectory("src")
+
+add_library( fem4ellipticpde ${FEMSOURCE} )  
+target_link_libraries(fem4ellipticpde "lemmacore")

include/FEM4EllipticPDE.h

+// ===========================================================================
+//
+//       Filename:  FEM4EllipticPDE.h
+//
+//        Created:  08/16/12 18:19:41
+//       Compiler:  Tested with g++, icpc, and MSVC 2010
+//
+//         Author:  Trevor Irons (ti)
+//
+//   Organisation:  Colorado School of Mines (CSM)
+//                  United States Geological Survey (USGS)
+//
+//          Email:  tirons@mines.edu, tirons@usgs.gov
+//
+//  This program is free software: you can redistribute it and/or modify
+//  it under the terms of the GNU General Public License as published by
+//  the Free Software Foundation, either version 3 of the License, or
+//  (at your option) any later version.
+//
+//  This program is distributed in the hope that it will be useful,
+//  but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of
+//  MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE.  See the
+//  GNU General Public License for more details.
+//
+//  You should have received a copy of the GNU General Public License
+//  along with this program.  If not, see <http://www.gnu.org/licenses/>.
+//
+// ===========================================================================
+
+/**
+  @file
+  @author   Trevor Irons
+  @date     08/16/12
+  @version   $Rev$
+ **/
+
+#ifndef  FEM4ELLIPTICPDE_INC
+#define  FEM4ELLIPTICPDE_INC
+
+#include "LemmaObject.h"
+#include "vtkImplicitFunction.h"
+#include "vtkDataSet.h"
+#include "vtkXMLDataSetWriter.h"
+#include "vtkSmartPointer.h"
+#include "vtkIdList.h"
+#include "vtkCell.h"
+#include "vtkDoubleArray.h"
+#include "vtkPointData.h"
+#include "vtkDataSetSurfaceFilter.h"
+#include "vtkCellArray.h"
+#include "vtkCellData.h"
+
+#include <Eigen/IterativeLinearSolvers>
+#include "DCSurvey.h"
+
+namespace Lemma {
+
+    /** @defgroup FEM4EllipticPDE
+     @brief Finite element solver for elliptic PDE's
+     @details Uses Galerkin method.
+    */
+
+    /** \addtogroup FEM4EllipticPDE
+     @{
+     */
+
+    // ===================================================================
+    //  Class:  FEM4EllipticPDE
+    /**
+      @class FEM4EllipticPDE
+      @brief Galerkin FEM solver for Elliptic PDE problems
+      @details Solves problems of the type
+        \f[ - \nabla  \cdot ( \sigma(\mathbf{r}) \nabla u(\mathbf{r}) ) = g(\mathbf{r})
+        \f]
+     */
+    class FEM4EllipticPDE : public LemmaObject {
+
+        friend std::ostream &operator<<(std::ostream &stream,
+			const FEM4EllipticPDE  &ob);
+
+        public:
+
+            // ====================  LIFECYCLE     =======================
+
+            /** Returns a pointer to a new object of type FEM4EllipticPDE.
+             * It allocates all necessary memory.
+             */
+            static FEM4EllipticPDE* New();
+
+            /** Deletes this object. Delete also disconnects any
+             * attachments to this object.
+             */
+            void Delete();
+
+            // ====================  OPERATORS     =======================
+
+            // ====================  OPERATIONS    =======================
+
+            /** Sets the vtkImplictFunction that is used as sigma in
+            \f$ - \nabla  \cdot ( \sigma(\mathbf{r}) \nabla u(\mathbf{r}) ) = g(\mathbf{r})
+            \f$. If this is not set, sigma evaluates as 1.
+             */
+            void SetSigmaFunction(vtkImplicitFunction* sigma);
+
+            /** Sets the step to be used in applying boundary conditions.
+             */
+            void SetBoundaryStep(const Real& h);
+
+            /** Sets the vtkImplictFunction that is used
+             */
+            void SetGFunction(vtkImplicitFunction* G);
+
+            /** Uses a function pointer instead of a vtkImplicitFunction. For functions that can
+             *  be written in closed form, this can be much faster and more accurate then interpolating
+             *  off a grid.
+             */
+            void SetGFunction( Real (*pFcn3)(const Real&, const Real&, const Real&) );
+
+            /** Sets the vtkDataSet that defines the calculation grid.
+             */
+            void SetGrid(vtkDataSet* Grid);
+
+            /** Sets up a DC problem with a survey
+             *  @param[in] ij is the injection index
+             */
+            void SetupDC(DCSurvey* Survey, const int& ij);
+
+            /** Performs solution */
+            void Solve(const std::string& fname);
+
+            /** Performs solution */
+            void SolveOLD(const std::string& fname);
+
+            // ====================  ACCESS        =======================
+
+            // ====================  INQUIRY       =======================
+
+        protected:
+
+            // ====================  LIFECYCLE     =======================
+
+            /// Default protected constructor.
+            FEM4EllipticPDE (const std::string& cname);
+
+            /** Default protected constructor. */
+            ~FEM4EllipticPDE ();
+
+            /**
+             * @copybrief LemmaObject::Release()
+             * @copydetails LemmaObject::Release()
+             */
+            void Release();
+
+            // ====================  OPERATIONS    =======================
+
+            /** Used internally to construct stiffness matrix, A
+             */
+            void ConstructAMatrix();
+
+            /* Used internally to construct the load vector, g
+             */
+            //void ConstructLoadVector();
+
+            // This function is copyright (C) 2012 Joseph Capriotti
+            /**
+                Returns a vtkIdList of points in member vtkGrid connected to point ido.
+                @param[in] ido is the point of interest
+                @param[in] grid is a pointer to a vtkDataSet
+            */
+            vtkSmartPointer<vtkIdList> GetConnectedPoints(const int& id0);
+
+            /** Uses Simpson's rule to numerically integrate
+             * (Shamelessly adapted from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simpson's_rule
+             */
+            Real CompositeSimpsons(vtkImplicitFunction* f, Real r0[3], Real r1[3], int numInt);
+
+            /** Uses Simpson's rule to numerically integrate
+             * (Shamelessly adapted from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simpson's_rule
+             *  this method is for a static f
+             */
+            Real CompositeSimpsons(const Real& f, Real r0[3], Real r1[3], int numInt);
+
+            /**
+             *  Uses Simpson's rule to numerically integrate two functions in 1 dimension over the points
+             *   r0 and r1
+             */
+            Real CompositeSimpsons2(vtkImplicitFunction* f, Real r0[3], Real r1[3], int numInt);
+
+            /**
+             *  Uses Simpson's rule to numerically integrate two functions in 1 dimension over the points
+             *   r0 and r1, uses the Hat function and the function pointer fPtr
+             */
+            Real CompositeSimpsons2(  Real (*fPtr)(const Real&, const Real&, const Real&), Real r0[3], Real r1[3], int numInt);
+
+            /**
+             *  Uses Simpson's rule to numerically integrate two functions in 1 dimension over the points
+             *   r0 and r1, uses the Hat function. Assumes a constand function value f
+             */
+            Real CompositeSimpsons2( const  Real& f, Real r0[3], Real r1[3], int numInt);
+
+            /**
+             *  Uses Simpson's rule to numerically integrate two functions in 1 dimension over the points
+             *   r0 and r1, uses the Hat function. Assumes a linear function from f0 to f1.
+             */
+            Real CompositeSimpsons2( const  Real& f0, const Real& f1, Real r0[3], Real r1[3], int numInt);
+
+            /**
+             *  Uses Simpson's rule to numerically integrate three functions in 1 dimension over the points
+             *   r0 and r1, uses two Hat functions. Assumes a linear function from f0 to f1.
+             */
+            Real CompositeSimpsons3( const  Real& f0, const Real& f1, Real r0[3], Real r1[3], int numInt);
+
+            /** Hat function for use in Galerkin FEM method, actually a 1/2 Hat.
+             */
+            //Real hat(Real r[3], Real ri[3], Real rm1[3] );
+            Real Hat(const Vector3r &r, const Vector3r& ri, const Vector3r& rm1 );
+
+            /** Computes distance between r0 and r1
+             */
+            Real dist(Real r0[3], Real r1[3]);
+
+            /** Computes distance between r0 and r1
+             */
+            Real dist(const Vector3r& r0, const Vector3r& r1);
+
+            // ====================  DATA MEMBERS  =========================
+
+            /** The effective step at the boundary condition. Defaults to 1
+             */
+            Real BndryH;
+
+            /** The sigma value at the boundary condition. Defaults to 1
+             */
+            Real BndrySigma;
+
+            /** Implicit function defining the \f$\sigma\f$ term in
+                \f$ - \nabla  \cdot ( \sigma(\mathbf{r}) \nabla u(\mathbf{r}) ) = g(\mathbf{r})
+                \f$.
+                If set to 1, the Poisson equation is solved. Any type of vtkImplicitFunction may
+                be used, including vtkImplicitDataSet.
+            */
+            vtkSmartPointer<vtkImplicitFunction>    vtkSigma;
+
+            /** Implicit function defining the \f$g\f$ term in
+                \f$ - \nabla  \cdot ( \sigma(\mathbf{r}) \nabla u(\mathbf{r}) ) = g(\mathbf{r})
+                \f$.
+                Typically this is used to define the source term.
+            */
+            vtkSmartPointer<vtkImplicitFunction>    vtkG;
+
+            /** Any type of vtkDataSet may be used as a calculation Grid */
+            vtkSmartPointer<vtkDataSet>             vtkGrid;
+
+            /** Function pointer to function describing g */
+            Real (*gFcn3)(const Real&, const Real&, const Real&);
+
+            Eigen::SparseMatrix<Real> A;
+
+            VectorXr                  g;
+
+        private:
+
+    }; // -----  end of class  FEM4EllipticPDE  -----
+
+    /*! @} */
+
+}		// -----  end of Lemma  name  -----
+
+#endif   // ----- #ifndef FEM4ELLIPTICPDE_INC  -----

src/CMakeLists.txt

+set (FEMSOURCE
+	${FEMSOURCE}
+	${CMAKE_CURRENT_SOURCE_DIR}/FEM4EllipticPDE.cpp
+	PARENT_SCOPE
+)

src/FEM4EllipticPDE.cpp

+// ===========================================================================
+//
+//       Filename:  FEM4EllipticPDE.cpp
+//
+//        Created:  08/16/12 18:19:57
+//       Compiler:  Tested with g++, icpc, and MSVC 2010
+//
+//         Author:  Trevor Irons (ti)
+//
+//   Organisation:  Colorado School of Mines (CSM)
+//                  United States Geological Survey (USGS)
+//
+//          Email:  tirons@mines.edu, tirons@usgs.gov
+//
+//  This program is free software: you can redistribute it and/or modify
+//  it under the terms of the GNU General Public License as published by
+//  the Free Software Foundation, either version 3 of the License, or
+//  (at your option) any later version.
+//
+//  This program is distributed in the hope that it will be useful,
+//  but WITHOUT ANY WARRANTY; without even the implied warranty of
+//  MERCHANTABILITY or FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE.  See the
+//  GNU General Public License for more details.
+//
+//  You should have received a copy of the GNU General Public License
+//  along with this program.  If not, see <http://www.gnu.org/licenses/>.
+//
+// ===========================================================================
+
+/**
+  @file
+  @author   Trevor Irons
+  @date     08/16/12
+  @version   0.0
+ **/
+
+#include "FEM4EllipticPDE.h"
+
+namespace Lemma {
+
+	std::ostream &operator<<(std::ostream &stream,
+				const FEM4EllipticPDE &ob) {
+
+		stream << *(LemmaObject*)(&ob);
+		return stream;
+	}
+
+	// ====================  LIFECYCLE     =======================
+
+	FEM4EllipticPDE::FEM4EllipticPDE(const std::string&name) :
+			LemmaObject(name), BndryH(1), BndrySigma(1),
+            vtkSigma(NULL), vtkG(NULL), vtkGrid(NULL), gFcn3(NULL) {
+	}
+
+	FEM4EllipticPDE::~FEM4EllipticPDE() {
+	}
+
+    void FEM4EllipticPDE::Release() {
+        delete this;
+    }
+
+    FEM4EllipticPDE* FEM4EllipticPDE::New( ) {
+        FEM4EllipticPDE* Obj = new FEM4EllipticPDE("FEM4EllipticPDE");
+        Obj->AttachTo(Obj);
+        return Obj;
+    }
+
+    void FEM4EllipticPDE::Delete() {
+        this->DetachFrom(this);
+    }
+
+    // ====================  OPERATIONS    =======================
+
+    void FEM4EllipticPDE::SetSigmaFunction(vtkImplicitFunction* sigma) {
+        vtkSigma = sigma;
+    }
+
+    void FEM4EllipticPDE::SetBoundaryStep(const Real& h) {
+        BndryH = h;
+    }
+
+    void FEM4EllipticPDE::SetGFunction(vtkImplicitFunction* g) {
+        vtkG = g;
+    }
+
+    void FEM4EllipticPDE::SetGFunction( Real (*gFcn)(const Real&, const Real&, const Real&) ) {
+    //    vtkG = g;
+        gFcn3 = gFcn;
+    }
+
+    void FEM4EllipticPDE::SetGrid(vtkDataSet* grid) {
+        vtkGrid = grid;
+    }
+
+    vtkSmartPointer<vtkIdList> FEM4EllipticPDE::GetConnectedPoints(const int& id0) {
+        vtkSmartPointer<vtkIdList> pointIds = vtkSmartPointer<vtkIdList>::New();
+        vtkSmartPointer<vtkIdList> cellList = vtkSmartPointer<vtkIdList>::New();
+        vtkGrid->GetPointCells(id0, cellList);
+        for(int i=0;i<cellList->GetNumberOfIds(); ++i){
+            vtkCell* cell = vtkGrid->GetCell(cellList->GetId(i));
+            if(cell->GetNumberOfEdges() > 0){
+                for(int j=0; j<cell->GetNumberOfEdges(); ++j){
+                    vtkCell* edge = cell->GetEdge(j);
+                    vtkIdList* edgePoints=edge->GetPointIds();
+                    if(edgePoints->GetId(0)==id0){
+                        pointIds->InsertUniqueId(edgePoints->GetId(1));
+                    } else if(edgePoints->GetId(1)==id0){
+                        pointIds->InsertUniqueId(edgePoints->GetId(0));
+                    }
+                }
+            }
+        }
+        return pointIds;
+    }
+
+    Real FEM4EllipticPDE::dist(Real r0[3], Real r1[3]) {
+        Real rm0 = r1[0] - r0[0];
+        Real rm1 = r1[1] - r0[1];
+        Real rm2 = r1[2] - r0[2];
+        return std::sqrt( rm0*rm0 + rm1*rm1 + rm2*rm2 );
+    }
+
+    Real FEM4EllipticPDE::dist(const Vector3r& r0, const Vector3r& r1) {
+        Real rm0 = r1[0] - r0[0];
+        Real rm1 = r1[1] - r0[1];
+        Real rm2 = r1[2] - r0[2];
+        return std::sqrt( rm0*rm0 + rm1*rm1 + rm2*rm2 );
+    }
+
+
+    //--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
+    //       Class:  FEM4EllipticPDE
+    //      Method:  SetupDC
+    //--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
+    void FEM4EllipticPDE::SetupDC ( DCSurvey* Survey, const int& ij ) {
+
+        ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
+	    // Load vector g, solution vector u
+        std::cout << "\nBuilding load vector (g)" << std::endl;
+	    g = VectorXr::Zero(vtkGrid->GetNumberOfPoints());
+        std::cout << "made g with "  << vtkGrid->GetNumberOfPoints() << " pnts" << std::endl;
+
+        int iia(0);
+        Real jja(0);
+        Survey->GetA( ij, iia, jja );
+        //g(ii) = jj;
+
+        int iib(0);
+        Real jjb(0);
+        Survey->GetB( ij, iib, jjb );
+        //g(ii) = jj;
+
+
+        /* 3D Phi */
+
+        for (int ic=0; ic < vtkGrid->GetNumberOfCells(); ++ic) {
+
+//             Eigen::Matrix<Real, 4, 4> C = Eigen::Matrix<Real, 4, 4>::Zero() ;
+//             for (int ip=0; ip<4; ++ip) {
+//                 double* pts =  vtkGrid->GetCell(ic)->GetPoints()->GetPoint(ip); //[ipc] ;
+//                 C(ip, 0) = 1;
+//                 C(ip, 1) =  pts[0];
+//                 C(ip, 2) =  pts[1];
+//                 C(ip, 3) =  pts[2];
+//             }
+
+//             Real V = (1./6.) * C.determinant();          // volume of tetrahedra
+//
+            vtkIdList* Ids = vtkGrid->GetCell(ic)->GetPointIds();
+            int ID[4];
+                ID[0] = Ids->GetId(0);
+                ID[1] = Ids->GetId(1);
+                ID[2] = Ids->GetId(2);
+                ID[3] = Ids->GetId(3);
+
+            //Real V = C.determinant();          // volume of tetrahedra
+            Real sum(0);
+            if (ID[0] == iia || ID[1] == iia || ID[2] == iia || ID[3] == iia ) {
+                std::cout << "Caught A electrode, injecting " <<  iia << std::endl;
+                //sum = 10;
+                //g(ID[iia]) += jja;
+                g(iia) += jja;
+            }
+            if (ID[0] == iib || ID[1] == iib || ID[2] == iib || ID[3] == iib) {
+                //sum = -10;
+                std::cout << "Caught B electrode, injecting " << iib << std::endl;
+                //g(ID[iib]) += jjb;
+                g(iib) += jjb;
+            }
+
+            //g(ID[0]) = sum; //(V/4.) * sum; // Why 3, Why!!!?
+            std::cout <<  "\r" << (int)(1e2*((float)(ic) / (float)(vtkGrid->GetNumberOfCells()))) << std::flush ;
+        }
+
+
+
+        return ;
+    }		// -----  end of method FEM4EllipticPDE::SetupDC  -----
+
+
+
+    void FEM4EllipticPDE::Solve( const std::string& resfile) {
+        ConstructAMatrix();
+        //ConstructLoadVector();
+
+        std::cout << "\nSolving" << std::endl;
+        ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
+        // Solving:
+        //Eigen::SimplicialCholesky<Eigen::SparseMatrix<Real>, Eigen::Lower > chol(A);  // performs a Cholesky factorization of A
+        //VectorXr u = chol.solve(g);
+
+        //Eigen::ConjugateGradient<Eigen::SparseMatrix<Real, Eigen::Lower >  Eigen::DiagonalPreconditioner > cg;
+        Eigen::ConjugateGradient< Eigen::SparseMatrix<Real>  > cg(A);
+
+        //Eigen::BiCGSTAB<Eigen::SparseMatrix<Real> > cg(A);
+        cg.setMaxIterations(3000);
+        //cg.compute(A);
+        //std::cout << "Computed     " << std::endl;
+
+        VectorXr u = cg.solve(g);
+        std::cout << "#iterations:     " << cg.iterations() << std::endl;
+        std::cout << "estimated error: " << cg.error()      << std::endl;
+
+        vtkDoubleArray *gArray = vtkDoubleArray::New();
+        vtkDoubleArray *uArray = vtkDoubleArray::New();
+            uArray->SetNumberOfComponents(1);
+            gArray->SetNumberOfComponents(1);
+        for (int iu = 0; iu<u.size(); ++iu) {
+            uArray->InsertTuple1(iu, u[iu]);
+            gArray->InsertTuple1(iu, g[iu]);
+        }
+        uArray->SetName("u");
+        gArray->SetName("g");
+        vtkGrid->GetPointData()->AddArray(uArray);
+        vtkGrid->GetPointData()->AddArray(gArray);
+
+        vtkXMLDataSetWriter *Writer = vtkXMLDataSetWriter::New();
+            Writer->SetInputData(vtkGrid);
+            Writer->SetFileName(resfile.c_str());
+            Writer->Write();
+            Writer->Delete();
+
+        gArray->Delete();
+        uArray->Delete();
+
+    }
+
+
+    //--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
+    //       Class:  FEM4EllipticPDE
+    //      Method:  ConstructAMatrix
+    //--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
+    void FEM4EllipticPDE::ConstructAMatrix (  ) {
+
+        /////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
+        // Build stiffness matrix (A)
+        std::cout << "Building Stiffness Matrix (A) " << std::endl;
+        std::cout << "\tMesh has " << vtkGrid->GetNumberOfCells()  << " cells "  << std::endl;
+
+
+  	    //Eigen::SparseMatrix<Real>
+        A.resize(vtkGrid->GetNumberOfPoints(), vtkGrid->GetNumberOfPoints());
+        std::vector< Eigen::Triplet<Real> > coeffs;
+
+        // Here we iterate over all of the cells
+        for (int ic=0; ic < vtkGrid->GetNumberOfCells(); ++ic) {
+
+            assert ( vtkGrid->GetCell(ic)->GetNumberOfPoints() == 4 );
+            // TODO, in production code we might not want to do this check here
+            if ( vtkGrid->GetCell(ic)->GetNumberOfPoints() != 4 ) {
+                std::cout << "DOOM FEM4EllipticPDE encountered non-tetrahedral mesh\n";
+                std::cout << "Number of points in cell " << vtkGrid->GetCell(ic)->GetNumberOfPoints() << std::endl ;
+                exit(1);
+            }
+
+            // construct coordinate matrix C
+            Eigen::Matrix<Real, 4, 4> C = Eigen::Matrix<Real, 4, 4>::Zero() ;
+            for (int ip=0; ip<4; ++ip) {
+                double* pts =  vtkGrid->GetCell(ic)->GetPoints()->GetPoint(ip); //[ipc] ;
+                C(ip, 0) = 1;
+                C(ip, 1) =  pts[0] ;
+                C(ip, 2) =  pts[1] ;
+                C(ip, 3) =  pts[2] ;
+            }
+
+            Eigen::Matrix<Real, 4, 4> Phi = C.inverse(); // nabla \phi
+            Real V = (1./6.) * C.determinant();          // volume of tetrahedra
+
+            vtkIdList* Ids = vtkGrid->GetCell(ic)->GetPointIds();
+            int ID[4];
+                ID[0] = Ids->GetId(0);
+                ID[1] = Ids->GetId(1);
+                ID[2] = Ids->GetId(2);
+                ID[3] = Ids->GetId(3);
+            Real sum(0);
+            Real sigma_bar = vtkGrid->GetCellData()->GetScalars()->GetTuple1(ic);
+
+            for (int ip=0; ip<4; ++ip) {
+                for (int ip2=0; ip2<4; ++ip2) {
+                    if (ip2 == ip) {
+                        // I apply boundary to Stiffness matrix, it's common to take the other approach and apply to the load vector and then
+                        //   solve for the boundaries? Is one better? This seems to work, which is nice.
+                        //Real bdry = V*(1./(BndryH*BndryH))*BndrySigma*bndryCnt( ID[ip] ); // + sum;
+                        Real bb = vtkGrid->GetPointData()->GetScalars("vtkValidPointMask")->GetTuple(ID[ip])[0];
+                        //std::cout << "bb " << bb  << std::endl;
+                        Real bdry = V*(1./(BndryH*BndryH))*BndrySigma*bb; // + sum;
+                        coeffs.push_back( Eigen::Triplet<Real> ( ID[ip], ID[ip2], bdry +  Phi.col(ip).tail<3>().dot(Phi.col(ip2).tail<3>() ) * V * sigma_bar ) );
+                    } else {
+                        coeffs.push_back( Eigen::Triplet<Real> ( ID[ip], ID[ip2],         Phi.col(ip).tail<3>().dot(Phi.col(ip2).tail<3>() ) * V * sigma_bar ) );
+                    }
+                    // Stiffness matrix no longer contains boundary conditions...
+                    //coeffs.push_back( Eigen::Triplet<Real> ( ID[ip], ID[ip2],         Phi.col(ip).tail<3>().dot(Phi.col(ip2).tail<3>() ) * V * sigma_bar ) );
+                }
+            }
+            std::cout <<  "\r" << (int)(1e2*((float)(ic) / (float)(vtkGrid->GetNumberOfCells()))) << std::flush ;
+        }
+        A.setFromTriplets(coeffs.begin(), coeffs.end());
+
+    }
+
+    void FEM4EllipticPDE::SolveOLD(const std::string& fname) {
+
+        Real r0[3];
+        Real r1[3];
+
+        /////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
+        // Surface filter, to determine if points are on boundary, and need
+        // boundary conditions applied
+        vtkDataSetSurfaceFilter* Surface = vtkDataSetSurfaceFilter::New();
+            Surface->SetInputData(vtkGrid);
+            Surface->PassThroughPointIdsOn(	);
+            Surface->Update();
+            vtkIdTypeArray* BdryIds = static_cast<vtkIdTypeArray*>
+                (Surface->GetOutput()->GetPointData()->GetScalars("vtkOriginalPointIds"));
+
+        // Expensive search for whether or not point is on boundary. O(n) cost.
+        VectorXi bndryCnt = VectorXi::Zero(vtkGrid->GetNumberOfPoints());
+        for (int isp=0; isp < Surface->GetOutput()->GetNumberOfPoints(); ++isp) {
+            //double* pts =  vtkGrid->GetCell(ic)->GetPoints()->GetPoint(ip); //[ipc] ;
+            // x \in -14.5 to 14.5
+            // y \in 0 to 30
+            bndryCnt(BdryIds->GetTuple1(isp)) += 1;
+        }
+
+        /////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
+        // Build stiffness matrix (A)
+        std::cout << "Building Stiffness Matrix (A) " << std::endl;
+        std::cout << "\tMesh has " << vtkGrid->GetNumberOfCells()  << " cells "  << std::endl;
+
+
+  	    Eigen::SparseMatrix<Real> A(vtkGrid->GetNumberOfPoints(), vtkGrid->GetNumberOfPoints());
+        std::vector< Eigen::Triplet<Real> > coeffs;
+
+        // Here we iterate over all of the cells
+        for (int ic=0; ic < vtkGrid->GetNumberOfCells(); ++ic) {
+
+            assert ( vtkGrid->GetCell(ic)->GetNumberOfPoints() == 4 );
+            // TODO, in production code we might not want to do this check here
+            if ( vtkGrid->GetCell(ic)->GetNumberOfPoints() != 4 ) {
+                std::cout << "DOOM FEM4EllipticPDE encountered non-tetrahedral mesh\n";
+                std::cout << "Number of points in cell " << vtkGrid->GetCell(ic)->GetNumberOfPoints() << std::endl ;
+                exit(1);
+            }
+
+            // construct coordinate matrix C
+            Eigen::Matrix<Real, 4, 4> C = Eigen::Matrix<Real, 4, 4>::Zero() ;
+            for (int ip=0; ip<4; ++ip) {
+                double* pts =  vtkGrid->GetCell(ic)->GetPoints()->GetPoint(ip); //[ipc] ;
+                C(ip, 0) = 1;
+                C(ip, 1) =  pts[0] ;
+                C(ip, 2) =  pts[1] ;
+                C(ip, 3) =  pts[2] ;
+            }
+
+            Eigen::Matrix<Real, 4, 4> Phi = C.inverse(); // nabla \phi
+            Real V = (1./6.) * C.determinant();          // volume of tetrahedra
+
+            vtkIdList* Ids = vtkGrid->GetCell(ic)->GetPointIds();
+            int ID[4];
+                ID[0] = Ids->GetId(0);
+                ID[1] = Ids->GetId(1);
+                ID[2] = Ids->GetId(2);
+                ID[3] = Ids->GetId(3);
+            Real sum(0);
+            Real sigma_bar = vtkGrid->GetCellData()->GetScalars()->GetTuple1(ic);
+
+            for (int ip=0; ip<4; ++ip) {
+                for (int ip2=0; ip2<4; ++ip2) {
+                    if (ip2 == ip) {
+                        // I apply boundary to Stiffness matrix, it's common to take the other approach and apply to the load vector and then
+                        //   solve for the boundaries? Is one better? This seems to work, which is nice.
+                        //Real bdry = V*(1./(BndryH*BndryH))*BndrySigma*bndryCnt( ID[ip] ); // + sum;
+                        Real bb = vtkGrid->GetPointData()->GetScalars("vtkValidPointMask")->GetTuple(ID[ip])[0];
+                        //std::cout << "bb " << bb  << std::endl;
+                        Real bdry = V*(1./(BndryH*BndryH))*BndrySigma*bb; // + sum;
+                        coeffs.push_back( Eigen::Triplet<Real> ( ID[ip], ID[ip2], bdry +  Phi.col(ip).tail<3>().dot(Phi.col(ip2).tail<3>() ) * V * sigma_bar ) );
+                    } else {
+                        coeffs.push_back( Eigen::Triplet<Real> ( ID[ip], ID[ip2],         Phi.col(ip).tail<3>().dot(Phi.col(ip2).tail<3>() ) * V * sigma_bar ) );
+                    }
+                    // Stiffness matrix no longer contains boundary conditions...
+                    //coeffs.push_back( Eigen::Triplet<Real> ( ID[ip], ID[ip2],         Phi.col(ip).tail<3>().dot(Phi.col(ip2).tail<3>() ) * V * sigma_bar ) );
+                }
+            }
+            std::cout <<  "\r" << (int)(1e2*((float)(ic) / (float)(vtkGrid->GetNumberOfCells()))) << std::flush ;
+        }
+        A.setFromTriplets(coeffs.begin(), coeffs.end());
+        //A.makeCompressed();
+
+        ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
+	    // Load vector g, solution vector u
+        std::cout << "\nBuilding load vector (g)" << std::endl;
+	    VectorXr g = VectorXr::Zero(vtkGrid->GetNumberOfPoints());
+        std::cout << "made g with "  << vtkGrid->GetNumberOfPoints() << " pnts" << std::endl;
+        // If the G function has been evaluated at each *node*
+        //        --> but still needs to be integrated at the surfaces
+        // Aha, requires that there is in fact a pointdata memeber  // BUG TODO BUG!!!
+        std::cout  << "Point Data ptr " <<  vtkGrid->GetPointData() << std::endl;
+        //if (  vtkGrid->GetPointData() != NULL && std::string( vtkGrid->GetPointData()->GetScalars()->GetName() ).compare( std::string("G") ) == 0 ) {
+        bool pe(false);
+        bool ne(false);
+        if ( true ) {
+
+            std::cout << "\nUsing G from file" << std::endl;
+
+            /* 3D Phi */
+            for (int ic=0; ic < vtkGrid->GetNumberOfCells(); ++ic) {
+
+                Eigen::Matrix<Real, 4, 4> C = Eigen::Matrix<Real, 4, 4>::Zero() ;
+                for (int ip=0; ip<4; ++ip) {
+                    double* pts =  vtkGrid->GetCell(ic)->GetPoints()->GetPoint(ip); //[ipc] ;
+                    C(ip, 0) = 1;
+                    C(ip, 1) =  pts[0];
+                    C(ip, 2) =  pts[1];
+                    C(ip, 3) =  pts[2];
+                }
+
+                Real V = (1./6.) * C.determinant();          // volume of tetrahedra
+                //Real V = C.determinant();          // volume of tetrahedra
+
+                vtkIdList* Ids = vtkGrid->GetCell(ic)->GetPointIds();
+                int ID[4];
+                    ID[0] = Ids->GetId(0);
+                    ID[1] = Ids->GetId(1);
+                    ID[2] = Ids->GetId(2);
+                    ID[3] = Ids->GetId(3);
+
+                /* bad news bears for magnet */
+                double* pt =  vtkGrid->GetCell(ic)->GetPoints()->GetPoint(0);
+                Real sum(0);
+                /*
+                if (!pe) {
+                    if (std::abs(pt[0]) < .2 && std::abs(pt[1]-15) < .2 && pt[2] < 3.25 ) {
+                        sum = 1; //vtkGrid->GetPointData()->GetScalars()->GetTuple(ID[ip])[0];
+                        pe = true;
+                    }
+                }*/
+                if (ID[0] == 26) {
+                    sum = 10;
+                }
+                if (ID[0] == 30) {
+                    sum = -10;
+                }
+
+/*
+                if (!ne) {
+                    if (std::abs(pt[0]+1.) < .2 && std::abs(pt[1]-15) < .2 && pt[2] < 3.25 ) {
+                        sum = -1; //vtkGrid->GetPointData()->GetScalars()->GetTuple(ID[ip])[0];
+                        std::cout << "Negative Electroce\n";
+                        ne = true;
+                    }
+                }
+*/
+                //for (int ip=0; ip<4; ++ip) {
+                    //g(ID[ip]) +=  (V/4.) *  ( vtkGrid->GetPointData()->GetScalars()->GetTuple(ID[ip])[0] )  ;
+                    //if ( std::abs(vtkGrid->GetPointData()->GetScalars()->GetTuple(ID[ip])[0]) > 1e-3 )
+                //}
+                // TODO check Load Vector...
+                g(ID[0]) = sum; //(V/4.) * sum; // Why 3, Why!!!?
+                std::cout <<  "\r" << (int)(1e2*((float)(ic) / (float)(vtkGrid->GetNumberOfCells()))) << std::flush ;
+            }
+
+            /*
+            for (int ic=0; ic < vtkGrid->GetNumberOfPoints(); ++ic) {
+                vtkGrid->GetPoint(ic, r0);
+                vtkSmartPointer<vtkIdList> connectedVertices = GetConnectedPoints(ic);
+                double g0 = vtkGrid->GetPointData()->GetScalars()->GetTuple(ic)[0] ;
+                //std::cout << "num conn " << connectedVertices->GetNumberOfIds() << std::endl;
+                if ( std::abs(g0) > 1e-3 ) {
+
+                    for(vtkIdType i = 0; i < connectedVertices->GetNumberOfIds(); ++i) {
+
+                        int ip = connectedVertices->GetId(i);
+                        vtkGrid->GetPoint(ip, r1);
+                        double g1 = vtkGrid->GetPointData()->GetScalars()->GetTuple(ip)[0] ;
+                        //g(ic) += g0*dist(r0,r1); //CompositeSimpsons2(g0, r0, r1, 8);
+                        if ( std::abs(g1) > 1e-3 ) {
+                            g(ic) += CompositeSimpsons2(g1, g0, r1, r0, 1000);
+                        }
+                        //g(ic) += CompositeSimpsons2(g0, r1, r0, 8);
+                        //if ( std::abs(g1) > 1e-3 ) {
+                            //g(ic) += CompositeSimpsons2(g0, g1, r0, r1, 8);
+                            //g(ic) += CompositeSimpsons2(g0, g1, r0, r1, 100); // / (2*dist(r0,r1)) ;
+                        //    g(ic) += g0*dist(r0,r1); //CompositeSimpsons2(g0, r0, r1, 8);
+                            //g(ic) += CompositeSimpsons2(g0, r0, r1, 8);
+                        //    g(ic) += g0; //CompositeSimpsons2(g0, r0, r1, 8);
+                        //} //else {
+                        //    g(ic) += g0; //CompositeSimpsons2(g0, r0, r1, 8);
+                        //}
+                    }
+                }
+                //g(ic) = 2.* vtkGrid->GetPointData()->GetScalars()->GetTuple(ic)[0] ; // Why 2?
+                //std::cout <<  "\r" << (int)(1e2*((float)(ic) / (float)(vtkGrid->GetNumberOfPoints()))) << std::flush ;
+            }
+            */
+
+        } else if (vtkG) { // VTK implicit function, proceed with care
+            std::cout << "\nUsing implicit file from file" << std::endl;
+            // OpenMP right here
+            for (int ic=0; ic < vtkGrid->GetNumberOfPoints(); ++ic) {
+                vtkSmartPointer<vtkIdList> connectedVertices = GetConnectedPoints(ic);
+                //vtkGrid->GetPoint(ic, r0);
+                //g(ic) += vtkG->FunctionValue(r0[0], r0[1], r0[2]) ;
+                // std::cout << vtkG->FunctionValue(r0[0], r0[1], r0[2])  << std::endl;
+                //g(ic) += vtkGrid->GetPointData()->GetScalars()->GetTuple1(ic);// FunctionValue(r0[0], r0[1], r0[2]) ;
+                /*
+                for(vtkIdType i = 0; i < connectedVertices->GetNumberOfIds(); ++i) {
+                    int ip = connectedVertices->GetId(i);
+                    vtkGrid->GetPoint(ip, r1);
+                    g(ic) += CompositeSimpsons2(vtkG, r0, r1, 8); // vtkG->FunctionValue(r0[0], r0[1], r0[2]) ;
+                }
+                */
+                std::cout <<  "\r" << (int)(1e2*((float)(ic) / (float)(vtkGrid->GetNumberOfPoints()))) << std::flush ;
+            }
+        } else if (gFcn3) {
+            std::cout << "\nUsing gFcn3" << std::endl;
+            for (int ic=0; ic < vtkGrid->GetNumberOfPoints(); ++ic) {
+                vtkSmartPointer<vtkIdList> connectedVertices = GetConnectedPoints(ic);
+                vtkGrid->GetPoint(ic, r0);
+                // TODO, test OMP sum reduction here. Is vtkGrid->GetPoint thread safe?
+                //Real sum(0.);
+                //#ifdef LEMMAUSEOMP
+                //#pragma omp parallel for reduction(+:sum)
+                //#endif
+                for(vtkIdType i = 0; i < connectedVertices->GetNumberOfIds(); ++i) {
+                    int ip = connectedVertices->GetId(i);
+                    vtkGrid->GetPoint(ip, r1);
+                    g(ic) += CompositeSimpsons2(gFcn3, r0, r1, 8); // vtkG->FunctionValue(r0[0], r0[1], r0[2]) ;
+                    //sum += CompositeSimpsons2(gFcn3, r0, r1, 8); // vtkG->FunctionValue(r0[0], r0[1], r0[2]) ;
+                }
+                std::cout <<  "\r" << (int)(1e2*((float)(ic) / (float)(vtkGrid->GetNumberOfPoints()))) << std::flush ;
+                //g(ic) = sum;
+            }
+        } else {
+            std::cout << "No source specified\n";
+            exit(EXIT_FAILURE);
+        }
+        // std::cout << g << std::endl;
+
+        //g(85) = 1;
+
+        std::cout << "\nSolving" << std::endl;
+        ////////////////////////////////////////////////////////////
+        // Solving:
+        //Eigen::SimplicialCholesky<Eigen::SparseMatrix<Real>, Eigen::Lower > chol(A);  // performs a Cholesky factorization of A
+        //VectorXr u = chol.solve(g);
+
+        //Eigen::ConjugateGradient<Eigen::SparseMatrix<Real, Eigen::Lower >  Eigen::DiagonalPreconditioner > cg;
+        Eigen::ConjugateGradient< Eigen::SparseMatrix<Real>  > cg(A);
+
+        //Eigen::BiCGSTAB<Eigen::SparseMatrix<Real> > cg(A);
+        cg.setMaxIterations(3000);
+        //cg.compute(A);
+        //std::cout << "Computed     " << std::endl;
+
+        VectorXr u = cg.solve(g);
+        std::cout << "#iterations:     " << cg.iterations() << std::endl;
+        std::cout << "estimated error: " << cg.error()      << std::endl;
+
+        vtkDoubleArray *gArray = vtkDoubleArray::New();
+        vtkDoubleArray *uArray = vtkDoubleArray::New();
+            uArray->SetNumberOfComponents(1);
+            gArray->SetNumberOfComponents(1);
+        for (int iu = 0; iu<u.size(); ++iu) {
+            uArray->InsertTuple1(iu, u[iu]);
+            gArray->InsertTuple1(iu, g[iu]);
+        }
+        uArray->SetName("u");
+        gArray->SetName("g");
+        vtkGrid->GetPointData()->AddArray(uArray);
+        vtkGrid->GetPointData()->AddArray(gArray);
+
+        vtkXMLDataSetWriter *Writer = vtkXMLDataSetWriter::New();
+            Writer->SetInputData(vtkGrid);
+            Writer->SetFileName(fname.c_str());
+            Writer->Write();
+            Writer->Delete();
+
+        Surface->Delete();
+        gArray->Delete();
+        uArray->Delete();
+
+    }
+
+    // Uses simpon's rule to perform a definite integral of a
+    // function (passed as a pointer). The integration occurs from
+    // (Shamelessly adapted from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simpson's_rule
+    Real FEM4EllipticPDE::CompositeSimpsons(vtkImplicitFunction* f, Real r0[3], Real r1[3], int n) {
+
+        Vector3r R0(r0[0], r0[1], r0[2]);
+        Vector3r R1(r1[0], r1[1], r1[2]);
+
+        // force n to be even
+        assert(n > 0);
+        //n += (n % 2);
+
+ 	    Real h  = dist(r0, r1) / (Real)(n) ;
+        Real S = f->FunctionValue(r0) + f->FunctionValue(r1);
+
+        Vector3r dr = (R1 - R0).array() / Real(n);
+
+        Vector3r rx;
+        rx.array() = R0.array() + dr.array();
+        for (int i=1; i<n; i+=2) {
+            S += 4. * f->FunctionValue(rx[0], rx[1], rx[2]);
+            rx += 2.*dr;
+        }
+
+        rx.array() = R0.array() + 2*dr.array();
+        for (int i=2; i<n-1; i+=2) {
+            S += 2.*f->FunctionValue(rx[0], rx[1], rx[2]);
+            rx += 2.*dr;
+        }
+
+        return h * S / 3.;
+
+    }
+
+    // Uses simpon's rule to perform a definite integral of a
+    // function (passed as a pointer). The integration occurs from
+    // (Shamelessly adapted from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Simpson's_rule
+    // This is just here as a convenience
+    Real FEM4EllipticPDE::CompositeSimpsons(const Real& f, Real r0[3], Real r1[3], int n) {
+
+        return dist(r0,r1)*f;
+        /*
+        Vector3r R0(r0[0], r0[1], r0[2]);
+        Vector3r R1(r1[0], r1[1], r1[2]);
+
+        // force n to be even
+        assert(n > 0);
+        //n += (n % 2);
+
+ 	    Real h  = dist(r0, r1) / (Real)(n) ;
+        Real S = f + f;
+
+        Vector3r dr = (R1 - R0).array() / Real(n);
+
+        //Vector3r rx;
+        //rx.array() = R0.array() + dr.array();
+        for (int i=1; i<n; i+=2) {
+            S += 4. * f;
+            //rx += 2.*dr;
+        }
+
+        //rx.array() = R0.array() + 2*dr.array();
+        for (int i=2; i<n-1; i+=2) {
+            S += 2. * f;
+            //rx += 2.*dr;
+        }
+
+        return h * S / 3.;
+        */
+    }
+
+
+    /*
+     *  Performs numerical integration of two functions, one is passed as a vtkImplicitFunction, the other is the FEM
+     *  test function owned by the FEM implimentaion.
+     */
+    Real FEM4EllipticPDE::CompositeSimpsons2(vtkImplicitFunction* f,
+            Real r0[3], Real r1[3], int n) {
+
+        Vector3r R0(r0[0], r0[1], r0[2]);
+        Vector3r R1(r1[0], r1[1], r1[2]);
+
+        // force n to be even
+        assert(n > 0);
+        //n += (n % 2);
+
+ 	    Real h  = dist(r0, r1) / (Real)(n) ;
+        // For Gelerkin (most) FEM, we can omit this one as test functions are zero valued at element boundaries
+        Real S = f->FunctionValue(r0) + f->FunctionValue(r1);
+        //Real S = f->FunctionValue(r0) + f->FunctionValue(r1);
+
+        Vector3r dr = (R1 - R0).array() / Real(n);
+
+        Vector3r rx;
+        rx.array() = R0.array() + dr.array();
+        for (int i=1; i<n; i+=2) {
+            S += 4. * f->FunctionValue(rx[0], rx[1], rx[2]) * Hat(rx, R0, R1) * Hat(rx, R1, R0);
+            rx += 2.*dr;
+        }
+
+        rx.array() = R0.array() + 2*dr.array();
+        for (int i=2; i<n-1; i+=2) {
+            S += 2. * f->FunctionValue(rx[0], rx[1], rx[2]) * Hat(rx, R0, R1) * Hat(rx, R1, R0);
+            rx += 2.*dr;
+        }
+
+        return h * S / 3.;
+
+    }
+
+    /*
+     *  Performs numerical integration of two functions, one is passed as a vtkImplicitFunction, the other is the FEM
+     *  test function owned by the FEM implimentaion.
+     */
+    Real FEM4EllipticPDE::CompositeSimpsons2( Real (*f)(const Real&, const Real&, const Real&),
+            Real r0[3], Real r1[3], int n) {
+
+        Vector3r R0(r0[0], r0[1], r0[2]);
+        Vector3r R1(r1[0], r1[1], r1[2]);
+
+        // force n to be even
+        assert(n > 0);
+        //n += (n % 2);
+
+ 	    Real h  = dist(r0, r1) / (Real)(n) ;
+        // For Gelerkin (most) FEM, we can omit this one as test functions are zero valued at element boundaries
+        //Real S = f(r0[0], r0[1], r0[2])*Hat(R0, R0, R1) + f(r1[0], r1[1], r1[2])*Hat(R1, R0, R1);
+        Real S = f(r0[0], r0[1], r0[2]) + f(r1[0], r1[1], r1[2]);
+
+        Vector3r dr = (R1 - R0).array() / Real(n);
+
+        Vector3r rx;
+        rx.array() = R0.array() + dr.array();
+        for (int i=1; i<n; i+=2) {
+            S += 4. * f(rx[0], rx[1], rx[2]) * Hat(rx, R0, R1) * Hat(rx, R1, R0);
+            rx += 2.*dr;
+
+        }
+
+        rx.array() = R0.array() + 2*dr.array();
+        for (int i=2; i<n-1; i+=2) {
+            S += 2. * f(rx[0], rx[1], rx[2]) * Hat(rx, R0, R1) * Hat(rx, R1, R0);
+            rx += 2.*dr;
+        }
+
+        return h * S / 3.;
+
+    }
+
+    /*
+     *  Performs numerical integration of two functions, one is constant valued f, the other is the FEM
+     *  test function owned by the FEM implimentaion.
+     */
+    Real FEM4EllipticPDE::CompositeSimpsons2( const Real& f, Real r0[3], Real r1[3], int n) {
+
+        Vector3r R0(r0[0], r0[1], r0[2]);
+        Vector3r R1(r1[0], r1[1], r1[2]);
+
+        // force n to be even
+        assert(n > 0);
+        //n += (n % 2);
+
+ 	    Real h  = dist(r0, r1) / (Real)(n) ;
+        // For Gelerkin (most) FEM, we can omit this one as test functions are zero valued at element boundaries
+        Real S = 2*f; //*Hat(R0, R0, R1) + f*Hat(R1, R0, R1);
+
+        Vector3r dr = (R1 - R0).array() / Real(n);
+
+        Vector3r rx;
+        rx.array() = R0.array() + dr.array();
+        for (int i=1; i<n; i+=2) {
+            S += 4. * f * Hat(rx, R0, R1) * Hat(rx, R1, R0);
+            rx += 2.*dr;
+        }
+
+        rx.array() = R0.array() + 2*dr.array();
+        for (int i=2; i<n-1; i+=2) {
+            S += 2. * f * Hat(rx, R0, R1) * Hat(rx, R1, R0);
+            rx += 2.*dr;
+        }
+
+        return h * S / 3.;
+
+    }
+
+    /*
+     *  Performs numerical integration of two functions, one is passed as a vtkImplicitFunction, the other is the FEM
+     *  test function owned by the FEM implimentaion.
+     */
+    Real FEM4EllipticPDE::CompositeSimpsons2( const Real& f0, const Real& f1, Real r0[3], Real r1[3], int n) {
+
+        Vector3r R0(r0[0], r0[1], r0[2]);
+        Vector3r R1(r1[0], r1[1], r1[2]);
+
+        // force n to be even
+        assert(n > 0);
+        //n += (n % 2);
+
+ 	    Real h  = dist(r0, r1) / (Real)(n) ;
+
+        // For Gelerkin (most) FEM, we can omit this one as test functions are zero valued at element boundaries
+        // NO! We are looking at 1/2 hat often!!! So S = f1!
+        Real S = f1; //f0*Hat(R0, R0, R1) + f1*Hat(R1, R0, R1);
+
+        Vector3r dr = (R1 - R0).array() / Real(n);
+
+        // linear interpolate function
+        //Vector3r rx;
+        //rx.array() = R0.array() + dr.array();
+        for (int i=1; i<n; i+=2) {
+            double fx = f0 + (f1 - f0) * ((i*h)/(h*n));
+            S += 4. * fx * Hat(R0.array() + i*dr.array(), R0, R1);// * Hat(R1.array() + i*dr.array(), R1, R0) ;
+        }
+
+        //rx.array() = R0.array() + 2*dr.array();
+        for (int i=2; i<n-1; i+=2) {
+            double fx = f0 + (f1 - f0) * ((i*h)/(h*n));
+            S += 2. * fx * Hat(R0.array() + i*dr.array(), R0, R1);// * Hat(R1.array() + i*dr.array(), R1, R0);
+        }
+
+        return h * S / 3.;
+
+    }
+
+    /*
+     *  Performs numerical integration of two functions, one is passed as a vtkImplicitFunction, the other is the FEM
+     *  test function owned by the FEM implimentaion.
+     */
+    Real FEM4EllipticPDE::CompositeSimpsons3( const Real& f0, const Real& f1, Real r0[3], Real r1[3], int n) {
+
+        Vector3r R0(r0[0], r0[1], r0[2]);
+        Vector3r R1(r1[0], r1[1], r1[2]);
+
+        // force n to be even
+        assert(n > 0);
+        //n += (n % 2);
+
+ 	    Real h  = dist(r0, r1) / (Real)(n) ;
+
+        // For Gelerkin (most) FEM, we can omit this one as test functions are zero valued at element boundaries
+        // NO! We are looking at 1/2 hat often!!! So S = f1!
+        Real S = f0+f1; //Hat(R0, R0, R1) + f1*Hat(R1, R0, R1);
+
+        Vector3r dr = (R1 - R0).array() / Real(n);
+
+        // linear interpolate function
+        //Vector3r rx;
+        //rx.array() = R0.array() + dr.array();
+        for (int i=1; i<n; i+=2) {
+            double fx = 1;// f0 + (f1 - f0) * ((i*h)/(h*n));
+            S += 4. * fx * Hat(R0.array() + i*dr.array(), R0, R1) * Hat(R1.array() + i*dr.array(), R1, R0) ;
+        }
+
+        //rx.array() = R0.array() + 2*dr.array();
+        for (int i=2; i<n-1; i+=2) {
+            double fx = 1; // f0 + (f1 - f0) * ((i*h)/(h*n));
+            S += 2. * fx * Hat(R0.array() + i*dr.array(), R0, R1)*  Hat(R1.array() + i*dr.array(), R1, R0);
+        }
+
+        return h * S / 3.;
+
+    }
+
+
+    //--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
+    //       Class:  FEM4EllipticPDE
+    //      Method:  Hat
+    //--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
+    Real FEM4EllipticPDE::Hat ( const Vector3r& r, const Vector3r& r0, const Vector3r& r1 ) {
+        //return  (r-r0).norm() / (r1-r0).norm() ;
+        return  dist(r, r0) / dist(r1, r0) ;
+    }		// -----  end of method FEM4EllipticPDE::Hat  -----
+
+
+}		// -----  end of Lemma  name  -----